Jello Creamsicle Pie

Introduction & Inspiration

There are desserts that taste like childhood memories, and this Jello Creamsicle Pie is one of them. The moment I took a bite, I was transported back to hot summer afternoons, sticky hands, and orange creamsicle popsicles dripping down my wrist.

I created this pie because I wanted something cool, creamy, and citrusy without needing to turn on the oven for hours. I wanted that nostalgic creamsicle flavor in a dessert that was light and refreshing yet still indulgent.

The result is a pie that’s part no-bake cheesecake, part frozen treat, and completely irresistible. It’s vibrant, easy to make, and always the first thing to disappear at potlucks and BBQs.

Once you try it, you’ll understand why this pie is now a staple in my summer dessert lineup. It’s sunshine on a plate—and the perfect way to end any warm-weather meal.

Nostalgic Appeal

The inspiration for this pie came straight from those classic orange creamsicle popsicles. They were my favorite as a kid. I loved how the bright citrus outside melted into the smooth vanilla center.

This pie captures that same contrast of flavors and textures. Every slice has a refreshing burst of orange paired with a creamy vanilla tang, layered over a buttery shortbread crust that adds just the right amount of crunch.

Growing up, we always had Jello in the pantry. My mom would whip up all kinds of layered desserts with it, and it became this fun, magical ingredient in our kitchen. That box of orange Jello brings back so many memories.

It feels like a dessert you’d find at a neighborhood party, set on a picnic table under the shade of a tree. It’s retro, fun, and wonderfully familiar—with just enough of a modern twist to make it feel new again.

Homemade Focus

Even though this pie uses some convenient ingredients like Cool Whip and Jello, it still has that special homemade touch. It’s not just about throwing everything in a bowl—it’s about layering flavors and taking care with each step.

I love the process of pulsing the shortbread cookies, mixing in the butter, and pressing it into the pie dish. There’s something satisfying about creating the crust with your hands, knowing it’s going to be the base for something delicious.

The orange puree isn’t just juice—it’s fresh orange slices, zest, and a bit of vanilla, blended to bring out all the flavor. It’s a step that adds brightness and freshness that you just can’t get from bottled juice.

And that whipped topping made from cream cheese and Cool Whip? It’s light, silky, and ties everything together. Each element is simple, but when you put them all together, it feels like something you made with love.

Flavor Goal

I wanted this pie to taste like a frozen creamsicle but with more depth. Something that would hit those sweet citrus notes and then melt into rich creaminess, without being too heavy.

The shortbread crust gives it a buttery foundation. It’s slightly salty and holds everything together while adding a little crunch to contrast the fluffy filling.

The filling itself is packed with orange flavor from both Jello and fresh orange puree. The cream cheese and sweetened condensed milk balance the tanginess with smooth, decadent sweetness.

Vanilla is the secret that pulls everything together. It rounds out the citrus and makes the whole dessert taste like a frozen orange cream bar in pie form.

Each bite is bright, creamy, and incredibly satisfying. It’s sweet without being overpowering, and citrusy without being sour. Just cool, clean, and delicious.

Ingredient Insights

Shortbread cookies form the base of this pie. They’re buttery, slightly crumbly, and add a melt-in-your-mouth texture that’s perfect with creamy fillings. I prefer them to graham crackers for the flavor alone.

Butter binds the crust and gives it richness. Melted and mixed into the crushed cookies, it creates a crust that holds firm but still has a tender bite.

Fresh orange slices bring juicy, natural sweetness and color to the puree. I always use a ripe, juicy orange, then add zest for that extra citrus fragrance.

Orange zest intensifies the orange flavor in a natural way. It’s full of essential oils that release a floral brightness in the pie.

Vanilla extract adds warmth and depth. It gives that classic creamsicle contrast, making the orange pop while also softening it with a cream-like aroma.

Orange juice helps thin out the puree and blend everything together. It also adds acidity to balance the richness of the filling.

Orange Jello is the flavor anchor. It gives the pie structure and a bold citrus kick. I love how it infuses the cream cheese with a vibrant, fruity tone.

Cream cheese gives the pie body and tang. When softened and whipped, it becomes velvety and adds a nice balance to the sweetness of the Jello and condensed milk.

Cool Whip lightens the texture and makes the filling airy and mousse-like. You can use homemade whipped cream, but the convenience and stability of Cool Whip work great here.

Sweetened condensed milk adds smoothness and a sweet, caramel-like flavor. It’s what gives the filling its luscious texture without needing extra sugar.

Orange slices and whipped topping are the perfect finishing touch. They add color, freshness, and just the right amount of flair.

Essential Equipment

You’ll need a deep pie dish to accommodate the layers of this pie. I like to spray mine with nonstick spray to make slicing and serving a breeze.

A food processor is ideal for crushing the cookies into fine crumbs. It also helps puree the orange mixture quickly and evenly.

Mixing bowls are essential for combining the crust, filling, and topping. I use one medium and one large bowl for convenience.

A stand mixer or hand mixer makes it easy to beat the cream cheese and Jello together. It helps achieve a smooth, lump-free filling.

A silicone spatula helps fold the ingredients gently, especially when working with Cool Whip. It keeps the mixture light and fluffy.

You’ll also need a knife and cutting board for prepping the orange and zesting. A fine zester is best to avoid getting the bitter white pith.

Chilling is key, so make sure you’ve got room in the fridge or freezer to set the pie before serving.

List of Ingredients (With Measurements)

For the Crust
3 cups shortbread cookies, crushed
¼ cup melted butter

For the Orange Puree
1 orange, peeled and sliced
2 tablespoons orange zest
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
¼ cup orange juice

For the Filling
1 box (3 oz) orange Jello
12 oz cream cheese, softened and cubed, divided
12 oz Cool Whip, divided
1 can (14 oz) sweetened condensed milk

For Garnish
Orange slices
Whipped topping (optional)

Step-by-Step Instructions

Spray a deep pie dish with nonstick spray. Set aside while you make the crust.

Pulse the shortbread cookies in a food processor until they resemble coarse sand. Transfer to a bowl and mix with melted butter until fully moistened.

Press the crust mixture into the bottom and up the sides of the pie dish. Use your fingers or a measuring cup to press it down evenly. Place the dish in the freezer to set while you make the filling.

Rinse out your food processor and add the peeled orange slices, zest, vanilla, and orange juice. Blend until completely smooth. Set the puree aside.

In a large mixing bowl or stand mixer, beat 8 ounces of cream cheese with the orange Jello powder. Beat until the mixture is smooth and creamy with no lumps.

Fold in the sweetened condensed milk and 8 ounces of Cool Whip. Mix gently until smooth and light.

Add the orange puree into the filling and beat again until everything is fully incorporated. You should have a fluffy, citrusy mixture that smells amazing.

Pour the filling into the prepared pie crust. Smooth the top with a spatula and tap the dish gently to remove any air bubbles.

Chill the pie in the refrigerator for at least 2 hours for a soft, creamy texture. For a firmer, frozen version, place in the freezer for about 1 hour.

In a small bowl, whip the remaining 4 ounces of cream cheese and Cool Whip until smooth. This creates a light cream topping.

Once the pie is fully set, spread or pipe the whipped cream mixture over the top. Garnish with fresh orange slices or extra zest for a fresh finish.

Troubleshooting

If your filling is too soft, it may need more time to chill. Always give it at least 2 hours in the fridge or 1 hour in the freezer.

Lumpy filling? Make sure your cream cheese is softened before mixing. Cold cream cheese doesn’t blend smoothly.

Crust too crumbly? Add an extra tablespoon of melted butter. That helps bind the crumbs together more firmly.

If your pie is too sweet, use less condensed milk or add a touch more cream cheese next time. You can also increase the citrus zest for balance.

Tips and Variations

Swap out the orange for tangerine or blood orange for a different citrus twist. Each variation offers its own unique flavor and color.

Use graham crackers or vanilla wafers instead of shortbread for the crust. Both give different textures and pair nicely with the filling.

Add a splash of orange liqueur to the puree for an adult twist. Just a tablespoon adds depth without overpowering the citrus.

Top with candied orange peel or a drizzle of white chocolate for a festive touch. It makes the pie look like it came from a pastry shop.

Make mini versions in cupcake tins for individual servings. They’re perfect for parties and picnics.

Serving and Pairing Suggestions

This pie is best served cold, straight from the fridge. It’s refreshing and creamy with just enough sweetness to satisfy without being heavy.

Serve it with iced tea, lemonade, or a citrus cocktail for a bright pairing. It also goes well with espresso or a sweet dessert wine.

Garnish each slice with a fresh orange wedge or mint sprig. The color contrast makes every slice look even more vibrant.

It’s perfect for birthdays, baby showers, or summer BBQs. You can even slice and freeze it in individual portions for an anytime treat.

If you’re looking for a light dessert after a rich meal, this pie is the perfect palate cleanser. Creamy, citrusy, and not overly sweet—it hits all the right notes.

Nutritional Information (Approx. Per Slice)

Calories: 370
Sugar: 30g
Sodium: 180mg
Fat: 22g
Saturated Fat: 13g
Unsaturated Fat: 8g
Trans Fat: 0g
Carbohydrates: 36g
Fiber: 1g
Protein: 4g
Cholesterol: 60mg

Print

Recipe Summary and Q&A

This Jello Creamsicle Pie is the perfect no-bake dessert for summer. With a shortbread crust, fluffy citrus filling, and creamy topping, it’s a crowd-pleaser with nostalgic flavor and modern flair.

Can I make it ahead of time?
Yes! This pie is best when chilled for at least a few hours, making it a perfect make-ahead dessert.

Can I freeze it?
Definitely. It firms up beautifully in the freezer and tastes like a frozen creamsicle bar.

Can I use store-bought orange juice?
You can, but fresh orange and zest give a much brighter, natural flavor.

This pie is playful, easy to make, and full of flavor. It’s one of those recipes I return to over and over again because it’s just that good.